Case Docket

Case Number: 613894  WC
Case Type: C  CIVIL ACTION
Case Subtype: 04  WILL CONTEST
Name : LOWER, NANCY G.
AKA : LOWER, NANCY GAIL


Date Code Description Reference Receipt Cost
04/08/22 01 Case Number (Daily Reporter) 10.00
04/08/22 03 Docketing & Index 15.00
04/08/22 04 Computerized Legal Research 3.00
04/08/22 05 Computer Fee 10.00
04/08/22 08 Dispute Resolution Fund 15.00
04/08/22 1.2 Civil Action Deposit Rec # 587997 150.00
04/08/22 16 Special Projects Fund 15.00
04/08/22 07 Legal Aid Trust Fund 26.00
04/08/22 2d Complaint for Will Contest (1) 24.00
04/08/22 3w Request for Issuance of Summons (2) .00
Donald Lee Lower, Individually and as
Executor
04/08/22 3w Request for Issuance of Summons (3) .00
John Doe One - Four
04/08/22 3w Request for Issuance of Summons (4) .00
John Doe Number Five - Eight
04/08/22 3w Request for Issuance of Summons (5) .00
John Doe Number Nine - Ten
04/08/22 ma30 Motion to Appoint Special Process Server (6) .00
04/08/22 a30 Entry Appointing Special Process Server (7) 5.00
Jeffrey Cremeans of Encore Process
Service and/or its associates
04/11/22 1q Summons (8) .00
04/11/22 c Copies for Service 1.60
04/11/22 1r Order to Serve - Jeffrey Cremeans, (9) .00
Encore Process Service to serve Donald
Lee Lower, Individually and as Executor
04/11/22 1r Order to Serve - Jeffrey Cremeans, (10) .00
Encore Process Service to serve Jams
William Lower
05/11/22 2t Answer of Defendant Donald Lee Lower, (11) .00
Individually and as Executor of Estate
of Nancy G. Lower
05/11/22 cos Certificate of Service (11) .00
06/17/22 md Plaintiff's Motion for Status (12) .00
Conference
06/17/22 cos Certificate of Service (12) .00
06/17/22 1e Entry Setting Hearing (13) 07/29/2022 5.00
11:00 AM
06/17/22 eb Exhibit A - Zoom Information (14) .00
07/05/22 md MOTION DOCKET: Motion for Leave to (15) .00
Withdraw as Counsel for Plaintiff
07/05/22 cos Certificate of Service (15) .00
07/14/22 e Entry Withdrawing Ehren W. Slagle (16) 5.00
and Collins & Slagle Co LPA as Counsel
of Record for Plaintiff Michael Scott
Lower
07/28/22 coco Notice of Appearance of Co-Attorney (17) .00
of Record - Bryce W. Burton enters his
appearance on behalf of Michael Scott
Lower for the Status Hearing
08/01/22 dr Digital Record of Hearing KAG .00
7/29/22 ZOOM
08/15/22 mo Magistrate's Order Setting Status (18) 09/16/2022 5.00
Conference 3:00 PM
08/15/22 eb Exhibit A - Zoom Information (18) .00
08/15/22 c Copies for Service 1.60
08/16/22 jcos Certificate of Service/Judicial Staff (19) .00
09/12/22 c2 Notice of Dismissal Of Counsel (20) .00
Bryce W Burton
09/13/22 ros Return of Service (21) .00
Donald Lee Lower
Donald Lee Lower, Executor
James William Lower
09/16/22 md MOTION DOCKET: Notice of Motion and (21) 7.00
Motion for Amended Complaint
09/16/22 cos Certificate of Service (21) .00
09/16/22 att Amended Complaint (21) .00
09/16/22 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 595965 7.00
09/19/22 mc Memorandum of Defendant Donald Lee (22) .00
Lower, Individually and as Executor of
Estate of Nancy G. Lower in Opposition
to Plaintiff Michael Scott Lower's
09/19/22 ex Motion to Amend the Complaint (22) .00
09/19/22 cos Certificate of Service (22) .00
09/21/22 mo Magistrate's Order (23) 5.00
09/22/22 jcos Certificate of Service/Judicial Staff (24) .00
09/23/22 rep Reply of Plaintiff Michael Scott Lower (25) .00
to Donald Lee Lower's Memorandum
Contra to Motion to Amend Complaint
File September 12, 2022
09/23/22 cos Certificate of Service (25) .00
09/27/22 cmw Certified Mail Returned/No Service (26) 1.00
James William Lower
Served by Plaintiff
09/27/22 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 596560 1.00
10/06/22 misc Plaintiffs Request for Production of (27) 1.00
Documents to Defendants Donald L.
Lower and James W. Lower
10/06/22 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 597089 1.00
10/17/22 cos Certificate of Service/Return of Service (28) .00
James William Lower
10/17/22 cos Certificate of Service/Return of Service (29) .00
Colin R Beach
James William Lower
11/02/22 md MOTION DOCKET: Motion of Defendant (30) 23.00
Donald Lee Lower, Individually, and
Donald Lee Lower Executor for Summary
Judgment
11/02/22 mem Memorandum in Support (30) .00
11/02/22 cos Certificate of Service (30) .00
11/02/22 eb Exhibits A, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, B, 1, C (30) .00
11/02/22 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 598408 23.00
11/10/22 ci ANNUAL PHYSICAL/ELECTRONIC - 2022 (31) .00
CASE INVENTORY-as required by:
OH Rules of Superintendence
Rule 38
11/14/22 misc Follow-Up to Plaintiff's Request for (32) .00
Production of Documents to Defendants
Donald L Lower and James W. Lower, to
Donald L Lower
11/14/22 misc Follow-Up to Plaintiff's Request for (33) .00
Production of Documents to Defendants
Donald L Lower and James W Lower, to
James W Lower
11/14/22 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 598842 .00
11/14/22 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 598842 7.00
11/28/22 cos Certificate of Service for Follow Up (34) .00
Request for Discovery
11/29/22 md MOTION DOCKET: Plaintiff's Motion to (35) .00
Compel Discovery from Defendant James W.
Lower
11/29/22 mem Memorandum in Support (35) .00
11/29/22 cos Certificate of Service (36) .00
11/29/22 md MOTION DOCKET: Plaintiff's Motion to (37) .00
Compel Discovery from Defendant Donald
L. Lower
11/29/22 mem Memorandum in Support (37) .00
11/30/22 md MOTION DOCKET: Motion for Continuance, (38) .00
Suspension and/or Abatement of Defendant
Donald L Lower's Motion for Summary
Judgment
11/30/22 md MOTION DOCKET: Motion for Continuance, (39) .00
suspension and/or Abatement of Defendant
Donald L. Lower's Motion for Summary
Judgment
11/30/22 cos Certificate of Service (40) .00
11/30/22 cos Certificate of Service (41) .00
11/30/22 cos Certificate of Service (42) .00
12/02/22 md MOTION DOCKET: Motion of Defendant (43) 1.00
Donald Lee Lower Individually & Executor
Estate of Nancy G Lower to Strike or
Alternatively Deny Plaintiff Michael
12/02/22 ex Scott Lower's Motion to Compel Discovery (43) .00
12/02/22 mem Memorandum in Support (43) .00
12/02/22 cos Certificate of Service (43) .00
12/02/22 md MOTION DOCKET: Motion of Defendant (44) .00
Donald Lee Lower Individually & Executor
Estate of Nancy G Lower to Strike or
Alternatively Deny Plaintiff Michael
12/02/22 ex Scott Lower's Motion for Continuance, (44) .00
suspension and/or Abatement of Summary
Judgment
12/02/22 mem Memorandum in Support (44) .00
12/02/22 cos Certificate of Service (44) .00
12/02/22 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 599854 1.00
12/13/22 rep Plaintiffs Response to Motion of (45) .00
Defendant Donald Lee Lower Individually
and Executor Estate of Nancy G Lower's
to Strike or Alternatively Deny Plaintif
12/13/22 ex Michael Scott Lowers Motion for (45) .00
Continuance, Suspension and/or
Abatement of Summary Judgment
12/13/22 rep Plaintiff's Response to Motion of (46) .00
Defendant Donald Lee Lower Individually
and Executor Estate of Nancy G Lower's
to Strike or Alternatively Deny
12/13/22 ex Plaintiff Michael Scott Lower's Motion (46) .00
to Compel Discovery
12/13/22 cos Certificate of Service (47) .00
12/13/22 cos Certificate of Service (48) .00
12/27/22 cos Certificate of Service (49) .00
12/27/22 cos Certificate of Service (50) .00
12/27/22 misc Copies of Returned Items (51) 3.00
01/03/23 misc Return of Service of Encore Process Serv (52) .00
01/03/23 misc Returned Items (53) 1.00
01/23/23 md MOTION DOCKET: Plaintiff's Motion for (54) .00
Sanctions - Willful Discovery Abuse
01/23/23 cos Certificate of Service (54) .00
01/23/23 md MOTION DOCKET: Plaintiff's Motion for (55) 28.00
Judicial/Probate Accounting
01/23/23 cos Certificate of Service (55) .00
01/23/23 att Miscellaneous Documents (55) .00
01/23/23 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 602050 25.00
01/24/23 cos Certificate of Service (56) .00
01/30/23 cmw Certified Mail Returned/No Service (57) .00
01/30/23 misc Plaintiff's Response - Not Complete (58) .00
Document
01/30/23 misc Plaintiff's Response - Not Complete (59) .00
Document
01/31/23 ros Return of Service to Colin Beach (60) .00
01/31/23 md MOTION DOCKET: Plaintiff's Motion for (61) 9.00
Disqualification of Defense Counsel
01/31/23 mem Memorandum in Support (61) .00
01/31/23 eb Exhibits 1 and 2 (61) .00
01/31/23 cos Certificate of Service (62) .00
01/31/23 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 602542 5.20
01/31/23 md MOTION DOCKET: Plaintiff's Motion for (63) .00
Status Conference
01/31/23 cos Certificate of Service (64) .00
01/31/23 cos Certificate of Service (65) .00
01/31/23 cos Certificate of Service (66) .00
02/02/23 md MOTION DOCKET: Motion of Defendant (67) .00
Donald Lee Lower, Individually and as
Executor of Estate of Nancy G Lower to
Strike Plaintiff Michael Scott Lower's
02/02/23 ex Motion for Sanctions (67) .00
02/02/23 cos Certificate of Service (67) .00
02/13/23 mc Plaintiff's Response in Opposition to (68) .00
Defedant's Motion to Strike the
Plaintiff's Rule 37 Motion for Sanction
Against Defendant
02/13/23 401 Affidavit of Plaintiff Michael Scott (69) 3.00
Lower in Opposition to Defendant Donald
Lower's Motion for Summary Judgment
02/13/23 eb Exhibit 1 - Assignment of Mortgage (69) .00
02/13/23 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 603210 3.00
02/15/23 cos Certificate of Service (70) .00
02/15/23 cos Certificate of Service (71) .00
02/23/23 e Entry Setting Remote Status Conference 03/24/2023 5.00
(72) 9:00 AM
02/23/23 eb Exhibit A - Zoom Information (73) .00
03/08/23 cos Certificate of Service of Affidvait of (74) .00
Plaintiff
03/08/23 cos Certificate of Service of Plaintiff's (75) .00
Response in Opposition
03/08/23 cos Certificate of Service of Plaintiff's (76) .00
Motion for Judicial Accounting etc.
03/08/23 cos Certificate of Service of Plaintiff's (77) .00
Motion for Judicial Accounting
03/08/23 cos Certificate of Service of Plaintiff's (78) .00
Motions
03/08/23 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 604343 5.00
03/08/23 md MOTION DOCKET: Plaintiffs Motion to (79) .00
Strike Defendants Response in Opposition
to Plaitniffs Motion to Disqualify
03/08/23 cos Certificate of Service (80) .00
03/08/23 misc Entry Setting Hearing that has already (81) .00
been filed
03/08/23 cos Certificate of Service (82) .00
03/08/23 cos Certificate of Service (83) .00
03/08/23 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 604344 5.00
03/20/23 md MOTION DOCKET: Plaintiff's Motion for (84) 13.00
Default Judgment Against Defendant
James W. Lower
03/20/23 eb Exhibits 1 and 2 (84) .00
03/20/23 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 604892 8.00
03/21/23 md MOTION DOCKET: Plaintiff's Motion for (85) 2.00
Contempt Against Defendant James W Lower
03/21/23 eb Exhibits 1 and 2 (85) .00
03/21/23 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 604909 2.00
03/21/23 cos Certificate of Service (86) .00
03/21/23 cos Certificate of Service (87) .00
03/21/23 cos Certificate of Service (88) .00
03/21/23 misc Certificate of Mailing (89) .00
03/24/23 md MOTION DOCKET: Plaintiffs Motion to (90) .00
Strike Defendant Donald Lower's Motion
for Leave to File Memorandum Response in
Opposition to Plaintiffs Motion to
03/24/23 ex Disqualify Counsel, Instanter (90) .00
03/24/23 cos Certificate of Service (90) .00
03/24/23 md MOTION DOCKET: Plaintiffs Motion for (91) .00
Sanctions: Subversion of Rule 5 Re:
Defendant Donald Lowers Motion for Leave
to File Memorandum in Opposition
03/24/23 ex Re: Repeat Violations, Instanter (91) .00
03/24/23 cos Certificate of Service (91) .00
03/24/23 mo Magistrate's Order Denying Motion for (92) 5.00
Leave to Amend Answer
03/24/23 mo Magistrate's Order Dismissing Motion for (93) 5.00
Accounting
03/24/23 md MOTION DOCKET: Defendant Donald Lee (94) 8.00
Lower, Individually and Executor of
Estate of Nancy G Lower's Motion for
Leave to File Memorandum in
03/24/23 ex Opposition to Plaintiffs Motion for (94) .00
Disqualification of Defense Counsel,
Instanter
03/24/23 mem Memorandum in Support (94) .00
03/24/23 cos Certificate of Service (94) .00
03/24/23 eb Exhibits A and B (94) .00
03/24/23 e Entry - PROPOSED ENTRY NOT (95) 5.00
APPROVED BY THE COURT
03/24/23 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 605172 13.00
03/24/23 dr Digital Record of Hearing KAG .00
3/24/23 ZOOM
03/27/23 mcos Certificate of Service (96) .00
04/06/23 rep Plaintiff's Reply to Memo in Opposition (97) 4.00
Re Motion to Disqualify
04/06/23 cos Certificate of Service (97) .00
04/06/23 att Attachments (97) .00
04/06/23 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 605931 14.00
04/14/23 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 606361 2.00
04/14/23 misc Plaintiff's Request for Admissions (98) 2.00
Directed to Defendant Donald Lower
04/14/23 cos Certificate of Service (98) .00
04/21/23 l LETTER: to Magistrate Green from James (99) .00
W. Lower
05/08/23 md MOTION DOCKET: Plaintiff's Motion for (100) 2.00
Contempt and Sanctions Directed Against
Defendant James W Lower
05/08/23 eb Exhibits 1 and 2 (100) .00
05/08/23 cos Certificate of Service (100) .00
05/08/23 misc Plaintiff's Request for Admissions (101) 6.00
Directed to Defendant James W Lower
05/08/23 eb Exhibits 1 and 2 (101) .00
05/08/23 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 607529 8.00
05/11/23 cos Certificate of Service (102) .00
05/11/23 cos Certificate of Mailing (103) .00
05/23/23 misc Plaintiff's 2nd Request for Admissions (104) 13.00
Directed to Defendant James W Lower
05/23/23 misc Plaintiff's 2nd Request for Admissions (105) 14.00
Directed to defendant Donald Lower
05/23/23 cos Certificate of Service (106) .00
05/23/23 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 608376 27.00
06/01/23 cos Certificate of Service (107) .00
06/28/23 mo Magistrate's Order Denying Motions for (108) 5.00
Contempt
06/28/23 mo Magistrate's Order on the (109) 5.00
Disqualification of Defense Counsel
06/28/23 mo Magistrate's Order on Motion for (110) 5.00
Sanctions and Motion to Strike
06/28/23 mo Magistrate's Order on MOtion to Compel (111) 5.00
Discovery
06/28/23 mo Magistrate's Order on Status (112) 5.00
Conference and Default Judgment
06/30/23 mcos Certificate of Service (113) .00
07/03/23 jcos Certificate of Service/Judicial Staff (114) .00
07/03/23 m18ob Objections of Defendant Donald Lee Lower (115) .00
Individually and a Executor of the
Estate of Nancy G Lower to Magistrate's
Order Filed June 28, 2023
07/03/23 mem Memorandum in Support (115) .00
07/03/23 cos Certificate of Service (115) .00
07/05/23 2t Answer of James W. Lower (116) .00
07/12/23 m18ob Objections to Magistrate's Decision (117) .00
07/12/23 cos Certificate of Service (117) .00
07/12/23 md MOTION DOCKET: Plaintiffs Motion to (118) 2.00
Compel Amended Responses from
Defendant Donald Lower Re: Plaintiff's
Request for Admissions or Alternatively
07/12/23 ex Have Responses Deemed Admitted (118) .00
07/12/23 cos Certificate of Service (118) .00
07/12/23 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 610756 27.00
07/13/23 m18ob Plaintiff's Amended Objection to (119) .00
Magistrate's Order of June 28, 2023
Re: Disqualification of Defense Counsel
and Response in Opposition to Defendants
07/13/23 ex Objection of Order (119) .00
07/13/23 cos Certificate of Service (119) .00
07/17/23 cos Certificate of Service (120) .00
07/31/23 401 Plaintiff's Affidavit Re: Defense (121) 31.00
Counsel's Conflict of Interest
07/31/23 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 611619 33.00
07/31/23 401 Plaintiff's Ohio Rev Code 2937.20 (122) 2.00
Affidavit in Support of Disqualification
of Inferior Court Judge and/or
Magistrate Judge
08/08/23 cos Certificate of Service (123) .00
09/05/23 md MOTION DOCKET: Plaintiff's Rule 60(B)(5) (124) 53.00
Motion Seeking Relief from Unjust
Operation of Law Instanter
09/05/23 eb Exhibits 1 - 3 (124) .00
09/05/23 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 613479 53.00
10/18/23 jd Judgment Entry Modifying Magistrate's (125) 7.00
Order and Denying Disqualification of
Magistrate
10/18/23 jcos Certificate of Service/Judicial Staff (126) .00
12/04/23 noa Notice of Appearance of Counsel (127) .00
- Attorney for Defendant
12/04/23 cos Certificate of Service (127) .00
12/11/23 md MOTION DOCKET: Plaintoffs Motion to (128) 1.00
compel Discovery and/orMotion for
Contempt and Sanctions Against Defendant
James Lower
12/11/23 cos Certificate of Service (128) .00
12/11/23 misc Plaintiffs Third Request for Admissions (129) 3.00
Directed to Defendant Donald Lower
12/11/23 cos Certificate of Service (129) .00
12/11/23 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 618192 11.00
12/14/23 md MOTION DOCKET: Motion to Order (130) .00
Mediation
12/14/23 cos Certificate of Service (130) .00
12/15/23 cos Certificate of Service (131) .00
12/21/23 md MOTION DOCKET: Plaintiffs Renewed (132) 5.00
Motion for Contemtp and Sanctions
Against Defendant James Lower
12/21/23 cos Certificate of Service (132) .00
12/21/23 eb Exhibit 1 (132) .00
12/21/23 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 618783 5.00
12/22/23 rep Plaintiffs Response in Opposition to (133) .00
Defendant Executors Motion to Order
Mediation Lower
12/22/23 cos Certificate of Service (133) .00
12/26/23 cos Certificate of Service (134) .00
12/26/23 cos Certificate of Service (135) .00
12/29/23 cor Correspondence Received (NOT EVIDENCE) (136) .00
01/26/24 md MOTION DOCKET: Plaintiff's Second Motion (137) .00
for Contempt and Sanctions Against
Defendant James Lower
01/26/24 cos Certificate of Service (137) .00
01/26/24 md MOTION DOCKET: Plaintiff's Motion for an (138) .00
Expense Bill and/or Order for an
Equitable Cost Sanction Against
Defendant Donald Lower Re: Reponses to
01/26/24 ex Plaintiff's Third Request for Admissions (138) .00
01/26/24 cos Certificate of Service (138) .00
01/26/24 md MOTION DOCKET: Plaintiff's Motion (139) 8.00
Seeking an Order Deeming Defendant
Donald Lower's Responses to Plaintiff's
Third Request for Admissions Ruled to be
01/26/24 ex Admitted (139) .00
01/26/24 cos Certificate of Service (139) .00
01/26/24 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 620374 8.00
01/26/24 eb Exhibit 1 (139) .00
01/31/24 mc Memorandum in Response to Plaintiffs (140) .00
Motion Seeking an Order Deeming
Defendant Donald Lowers Responses to
Plaintiffs Third Request for Admission
01/31/24 ex to be Admitted (140) .00
01/31/24 cos Certificate of Service (140) .00
01/31/24 mc Memorandum in Response to Plaintiffs (141) .00
Motion for an Expense Bill and/or Order
for an Equitable Cost Sanction Against
Defendant Donal Lower Re: Responses
01/31/24 ex to Plaintiffs Third Request for (141) .00
Admissions
01/31/24 cos Certificate of Service (141) .00
01/31/24 cos Certificate of Service (142) .00
02/06/24 rep Plainitffs Response to Memorandum in (143) 3.00
Response to Plaintiffs Motion for an
Expense Bill and/or Order for an
Equitable Cost Sanction Against
02/06/24 ex Defendant Donald Lower RE: Response (143) .00
to Plaintiffs Third Request for
Admissions
02/06/24 mem Plaintiffs Response to Memorandum in (144) 3.00
Response to Plaintiffs Motion Seeking an
Order Deeming Defendant Donald Lowers
Responses to Plaintiffs Third Request
02/06/24 ex for Admissions Rule to be Admitted (144) .00
02/06/24 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 620970 6.00
02/07/24 rep Defendants Response to Plaintiff (145) .00
Practicing Law Without a License and
Response to Frivolous Lawsuit
02/07/24 cos Certificate of Service (145) .00
02/27/24 rep Plaintiff's Reply to Defendant James (146) 35.00
Lower's Response of February 7, 2024
and Motion for Contempt, Sanctions and
Relief
02/27/24 cos Certificate of Service (146) .00
02/27/24 eb Exhibit 1 - Plaintiffs First Request for (146) .00
Discovery Propounded on James Lower
02/27/24 eb Exhibit 2 - Plaintiffs Second Request (146) .00
for Discovery Propounded on James Lower
02/27/24 eb Exhibit 3 - Motion to Compel Against (146) .00
Defendant James Lower Due to his
Failures to Answer the Two Outstanding
Discovery/Admission Requests
02/27/24 eb Exhibit 4 - Certificate of Service for (146) .00
Plantiffs Request for Discovery
Propounded on James Lower
02/27/24 eb Exhibit 5 - Certificate of Service for (146) .00
Plaintiffs Second Request for Discovery
Propounded on James Lower
02/27/24 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 621984 35.00
03/01/24 cos Certificate of Service (147) .00
03/01/24 att Supporting Documentatio for COS for (148) .00
for Plainiff's Reply to Defendant James
Lower's Response to February 7, 2024 and
Motion for Contempt Sanctions and Relief
03/08/24 rep Response to Plaintiffs Reply to (149) 2.00
February 7, 2024
03/08/24 cos Certificate of Service (149) .00
03/08/24 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 622543 2.00
03/20/24 md MOTION DOCKET: Plaintiffs Motion (150) .00
Seeking Rule 11 Sanctions for Judicial
Abuse Re: Defendants Failure to
Withdraw Motion for Summary Judgment
03/20/24 md MOTION DOCKET: Plaintiffs Motion to (151) .00
Strike Defense Withess Colin Beach,
Esquire and Rule 11 Sanctions Against
Counsel for Defendant Donald Lower
03/27/24 mc Memorandum in Opposition to Plaintiffs (152) .00
Motion to Strike Defense Witness Colin
Beach, Esquire and Rule 11 Sanctions
Against Cousnel for Def Donald Lower
03/27/24 mc Memorandum in Opposition to Plaintiffs (153) .00
Motion Seeking Rule 11 Sanctions for
Judicial Abuse Re: Defendants Failure to
Withdraw Motion for Summary Judgment
04/01/24 md MOTION DOCKET: Plaintiff's Motion (154) 4.00
Seeking Sanctions Pursuant to
ORC 2323.51 and Civil Rule 11
Re: Defendant James Lowers Unsigned
04/01/24 ex Reponse (154) .00
04/01/24 eb Exhibit 1 - Defendants Response to (154) .00
Plaintiff Practicing Law Without a
License and Response to Frivolous
Lawsuit
04/01/24 mem Plaintiffs Reply to Defendant Donald (155) .00
Lowers Response in Opposition Re
Defendants Failure to Withdraw Summary
Judgment Motion
04/01/24 mem Plaintiffs Reply to Defendant Donald (156) 1.00
Lowers Response in Opposition Re
Plaintiffs Motion to Strike Witness &
Sanctions Against Defense Counsel
04/01/24 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 623714 5.00
04/01/24 cos Certificate of Service (157) .00
04/02/24 cos Certificate of Service (158) .00
04/09/24 1e Entry Setting Hearing (159) 05/01/2024 5.00
2:00 PM
04/09/24 mo Magistrate's Order Denying Plaintiffs (160) 5.00
Discovery Motions
04/09/24 eb Exhibit A - Zoom Information (161) .00
04/11/24 md MOTION DOCKET: Motion for Sanctions (162) 4.00
Against Michael Lower
04/11/24 mem Memorandum in Support (162) .00
04/11/24 cos Certificate of Service (162) .00
04/11/24 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 624227 4.00
04/15/24 mcos Certificate of Service (163) .00
04/16/24 md MOTION DOCKET: Request Cease and (164) .00
Desist Order
04/16/24 cos Certificate of Service (164) .00
04/19/24 md MOTION DOCKET: Plaintiffs Motion to (165) 8.00
Set Aside and Objection to Magistrate's
Order of April 9, 2024, Denying
Plaintiffs Discovery Motion
04/19/24 md MOTION DOCKET: Plaintiffs Motion for (166) .00
Continuance of Magistrate Hearing of
May 1, 2024
04/19/24 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 624623 18.00
04/19/24 401 Plaintiffs Affidavit in Support for the (167) 3.00
Removal of the Magistrate from
Remainter Proceedings
04/19/24 cos Certificate of Service of Affidavit (168) .00
04/19/24 cos Certificate of Service of Motion for (169) .00
Continuance
04/19/24 cos Certificate of Service for Plaintiffs (170) .00
Objection and Motion to Set Aside
04/19/24 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 624635 3.00
04/19/24 cos Certificate of Service (171) .00
04/25/24 mc Plaintiffs Response in Opposition to (172) 3.00
Defendant Donald Lowers Motion for
Sanctions
04/25/24 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 625022 3.00
04/26/24 rep Plaintiffs REsponse in Opposition to (173) .00
Defendant James Lower's Motion to Cease
and Desist
04/26/24 cos Certificate of Service (173) .00
04/29/24 cos Certificate of Service (174) .00
05/01/24 mo Magistrate's Order - Ordered this matter (175) 5.00
to proceed under the Ohio Rules of
Civil Procedure and Local Rules
05/01/24 dr Digital Record of Hearing TAS .00
05/01/2024 / 22B
2:05:35pm-2:11:42pm
05/02/24 poa Exhibit (176) 1.00
05/02/24 401 Plaintiffs Affidavit in Support of (177) .00
holding Party Defendant James Lower
Subject to Claims of Pleadings
05/02/24 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 625332 6.00
05/02/24 mcos Certificate of Service (178) .00
05/07/24 cos Certificate of Service (179) .00
05/07/24 cos Certificate of Service (180) .00
05/08/24 rep Response to Plaintiffs Affidavit in (181) .00
Support of Holding Party Defendant James
Lower Subject to Claims of Pleadings
05/08/24 cos Certificate of Service (181) .00
05/29/24 md MOTION DOCKET: Motion for Court to (182) .00
Serve All Process to Plaintiff
05/29/24 cos Certificate of Service (182) .00
05/29/24 eb Exhibit A - Letter Refused (182) .00
06/12/24 mc Plaintiffs Response in Opposition to (183) .00
Defendant James Lowers Motion to Have
Court Serve Process on Plaintiff
06/12/24 cos Certificate of Service (183) .00
06/12/24 md MOTION DOCKET: Plaintiffs Reply and (184) .00
Motion to Strike Defendant James Lowers
Response to Plaintiffs Affidavit
06/12/24 cos Certificate of Service (184) .00
06/12/24 mc Plaintiffs Response in Opposition to (185) .00
Defendant James Lowers Motion to Have
Court Serve Process on Plaintiff
06/12/24 cos Certificate of Service (185) .00
06/12/24 eb Exhibit 1 - Certified Mail Refused (185) .00
06/12/24 md MOTION DOCKET: Plaintiffs Reply and (186) .00
Motion to Strike Defendant James Lowers
Resposne to the Plaintiffs Affidavit
06/12/24 cos Certificate of Service (186) .00
06/14/24 401 Plaintiff's Affidavit to Clarify Undue (187) 5.00
Influence and Elder Abuse Claims
by Michael Scott Lower
06/14/24 cos Certificate of Service (187) .00
06/14/24 1.4 Subpoena (Attorney to Serve) (188) 12.00 .00
Rec # 627535
06/14/24 1.4 Subpoena (Attorney to Serve) (189) 12.00 .00
Rec # 627535
06/14/24 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 627535 29.00
06/20/24 cos Certificate of Service (190) .00
06/28/24 rep Response to Plaintiffs Motion to Strike (191) .00
Defendants Response to Plaintiffs
Affidavit - Defendant James Lower
06/28/24 cos Certificate of Service (191) .00
06/28/24 rep Response to Plaintiffs Motion in (192) .00
Opposition to Court Service to Plaintiff
- James Lower
06/28/24 cos Certificate of Service (192) .00
06/28/24 rep Response to Plaintiffs Affidavit to (193) 4.00
Clarify Undue Influence and Elder Abuse
Claims
06/28/24 cos Certificate of Service (193) .00
06/28/24 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 628154 4.00
07/22/24 md MOTION DOCKET: Plaintiffs Motion to (194) 6.00
Strike Defendant James Lower's Sham,
Frivolous and Vexatious Filings
07/22/24 cos Certificate of Service (194) .00
07/22/24 eb Exhibit 1 - Service Refused by Defendant (194) .00
James Lower
08/02/24 misc Plaintiff's Memorandum Re: Documents (195) 15.00
Produced from Subpoena of Columbus
Police Department
08/13/24 cos Certificate of Service (196) .00
08/19/24 e Judgment Entry Overruling Objections and (197) 5.00
Adopting Magistrate's Decision
08/19/24 cos Certificate of Service (197) .00
08/27/24 mo Magistrate's Order Setting Status (198) 10/02/2024 5.00
Conference 9:00 AM
08/27/24 eb Exhibit A - Zoom Information (198) .00
08/27/24 mo Magistrate's Order on Motion to (199) 5.00
Consolidate - Not well taken and is
DENIED
08/27/24 mo Magistrate's Order on Motion for (200) 5.00
Cease and Desist - Not well taken and is
DENIED
08/27/24 mo Magistrate's Order on Motion for Court (201) 5.00
to Serve All Process - is DISMISSED
08/27/24 mo Magistrate's Order on Motion to Strike (202) 5.00
- Not well taken and is DENIED
08/27/24 mo Magistrate's Order on Motion to Strike (203) 5.00
- DISMISSED AS MOOT
08/29/24 mcos Certificate of Service (204) .00
09/06/24 401 Plaintiffs Ohio Rev Code 2937.20 (205) 12.00
Affidavit in Support of Disqualification
of Inferior Court Judge and/or
Magistrate Judge and in Support of
09/06/24 ex Case to be Heard by a Visiting Judge (205) .00
09/06/24 eb Exhibits 1 - 3 (205) .00
09/06/24 cos Certificate of Service (205) .00
09/06/24 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 631607 44.00
09/09/24 cos Certificate of Service (206) .00
09/16/24 m39 Notice of Appeal (Civil/Mental) (207) .00
09/16/24 misc Docketing Statement (208) .00
09/16/24 misc Appellant Initial Intelocutory Brief (209) 12.00
09/16/24 misc Judgment Entry Overruling Objections (210) .00
and Adopting Magistrates Decision
09/16/24 cos Certificate of Service (211) .00
09/16/24 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 632158 12.00
09/30/24 misc Court of Appeals Journal Entry of (212) .00
Dismissal 24AP-571
10/10/24 e Entry Denying Plaintiffs Motion for (213) 5.00
Disqualification as Improperly Filed
10/11/24 jcos Certificate of Service/Judicial Staff (214) .00
10/17/24 mo Magistrate's Scheduling Order (215) 5.00
10/17/24 eb Exhibit A - Zoom Information (215) .00
10/17/24 omed Magistrate's Order Referring Matter to (216) 5.00
Mediation
10/18/24 mcos Certificate of Service (217) .00
11/15/24 md MOTION DOCKET: Plaintiffs Motion to (218) 33.00
Disqualify Magistrate Kelly Green
11/15/24 eb Exhibits (218) .00
11/15/24 401 Plaintiffs Ohio Rev. Code 2701.031 (219) 23.00
Affidavit in Support of Disqualification
of Magistrte Kelly Green
11/15/24 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 635314 71.00
11/22/24 cos Certificate of Service (220) .00
11/22/24 cos Certificate of Service (221) .00
11/22/24 cos Certificate of Service (222) .00
11/22/24 cos Certificate of Service (223) .00
11/22/24 2.1 Notice of Mediator Appointment (224) .00
Arnold S. White, Mediator
11/22/24 jcos Certificate of Service/Judicial Staff (225) .00
11/27/24 misc Plaintiffs Notice of Written Discovery (226) .00
Requests Propounded Upon
Defendants
11/27/24 md MOTION DOCKET: Plaintiffs Motion to (227) 7.00
Compel Specific Relevant Probative
Eviende from the Defendants
11/27/24 md MOTION DOCKET: Plaintiffs Motion for (228) 9.00
Leave to Join Party and File an Amended
Complaint
11/27/24 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 635966 16.00
12/06/24 2t Notarized Answer to Plaintiff's Request (229) .00
for Discovery by James W Lower
12/06/24 cos Certificate of Service (229) .00
12/06/24 2t Answer and/or Response to Plaintiff's (230) .00
Written Discovery Requests Submitted
11/27/2024 by James W Lower
12/06/24 cos Certificate of Service (230) .00
12/10/24 md MOTION DOCKET: Plaintiffs Rule 60(B) (231) 3.00
Motion for Reconsideration of Plaintiffs
Affidavit to Disqualify the Magistrate.
12/10/24 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 636460 3.00
12/20/24 misc Plaintiffs Initial Witness List (232) .00
12/20/24 cos Certificate of Service (232) .00
12/20/24 noa Notice of Appearance of Counsel (233) .00
Adam J. Bennett of Cooke Demers LLC
Enters His Appearance on Behalf of
Donald Lee Lower in his Individual
12/20/24 ex Capacity. (233) .00
12/20/24 cos Certificate of Service (233) .00
12/20/24 misc Defendant Donald Lee Lowers Disclosure (234) .00
of Witnesses
12/20/24 cos Certificate of Service (234) .00
12/20/24 misc Initial Witness Disclosure for Donald (235) .00
Lower as Executor
12/20/24 cos Certificate of Service (235) .00
12/20/24 misc Defendants Initial Witness List (236) .00
12/20/24 cos Certificate of Service (236) .00
01/14/25 rep Defendants Response to Plaintiffs Reply (237) .00
to Memorandum in Response to Motion for
Reconsideration of Courts Approval of
Estates Inventory and Accounts
01/14/25 cos Certificate of Service (237) .00
01/16/25 rep Plaintiffs Reply to Defendants Sham, (238) 4.00
Frivolous and Vexatious Response to
Plaintiffs Reply to Memorandum in
Response to Motion for Reconsideration
01/16/25 ex of Courts Approval of Estates Inventory (238) .00
and Accounts
01/16/25 cos Certificate of Service (238) .00
01/16/25 eb Exhibit 1 (238) .00
01/16/25 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 638071 4.00
01/27/25 md MOTION DOCKET: Plaintiffs Motion to (239) 13.00
Compel Better Discovery Responses from
Defendant Donald Lower and Defendant
James Lower
01/27/25 cos Certificate of Service (239) .00
01/27/25 eb Exhibits 1 - 3 (239) .00
01/27/25 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 638606 13.00
02/04/25 mc MEMORANDUM in Opposition to Motion to (240) 2.00
Compel
02/04/25 eb Exhibit A - Plaintiffs Notice of Written (241) .00
Discovery Requests Propounded Upon
Defendants
02/04/25 eb Exhibit B - Donald Lower Response to (242) 3.00
Michael Lower Request for Discovery
02/04/25 eb Exhibit C - eMail (243) .00
02/04/25 eb Exhibit D - eMail (244) .00
02/04/25 eb Exhibit E - eMail (245) .00
02/04/25 eb Exhibit F - Letter (246) .00
02/04/25 eb Exhibit G - eMail (247) .00
02/04/25 eb Exhibit H - eMail (248) .00
02/04/25 eb Exhibit I - Letter (249) .00
02/04/25 eb Exhibit J - eMail (250) .00
02/04/25 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 639065 5.00
02/06/25 m39 Notice of Appeal (Civil/Mental) (251) 3.00
02/06/25 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 639193 3.00
02/10/25 rep Plaintiffs Response to Defendant Donald (252) .00
Lowers Memorandum in Opposition to
Motion to Compel
02/10/25 cos Certificate of Service (252) .00
02/11/25 md MOTION DOCKET: Defendant Donald Lee (253) .00
Lowers Renewed Motion for Summary
Judgment in His Individual Capacity Only
02/11/25 cos Certificate of Service (253) .00
02/11/25 cos Certificate of Service (254) .00
02/13/25 misc Final Witness Disclosure (255) .00
02/13/25 cos Certificate of Service (255) .00
02/13/25 misc Defendant Donald Lee Lowers Disclosure (256) .00
of Witnesses
02/13/25 cos Certificate of Service (256) .00
02/19/25 misc Plaintiff's Updated Witness List (257) 1.00
02/19/25 cos Certificate of Service (257) .00
02/19/25 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 639773 1.00
02/19/25 misc Plaintiff's Updated Witness List (258) 1.00
02/19/25 cos Certificate of Service (258) .00
02/19/25 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 639776 1.00
02/20/25 md MOTION DOCKET: Plaintiff's Response in (259) 16.00
Opposition to Defendant Donald Lower's
Renewed Summary Judgment Motion &
Motion for Continuance
02/20/25 eb Exhibits 1 & 2 (259) .00
02/20/25 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 639926 16.00
02/20/25 cos Certificate of Service (259) .00
02/24/25 dr Digital Record of Hearing KAG .00
02/24/2025 / Zoom
03/03/25 md MOTION DOCKET: Executor's Renewed (260) .00
Motion for Summary Judgment
03/03/25 mem Memorandum in Support (260) .00
03/03/25 cos Certificate of Service (260) .00
03/05/25 md MOTION DOCKET: Plaintiff's Motion for (261) 9.00
Evidentiary Fact Stipulations
03/05/25 cos Certificate of Service (261) .00
03/05/25 eb Exhibit 1 Response to Plaintiff's (261) .00
Affidavit to Clarify Undue Influence and
Elder Abuse Claims
03/05/25 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 640682 9.00
03/06/25 md MOTION DOCKET: Plaintiff's Response in (262) 16.00
Opposition to Defendant Donald Lower, as
Executor of the Estate of Nancy Lower's
Renewed Summary Judgement Motion
03/06/25 ex & Motion for Continuance (262) .00
03/06/25 eb Exhibits 1 & 2 (262) .00
03/06/25 cos Certificate of Service (262) .00
03/06/25 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 640771 16.00
03/07/25 e Entry/Notice for Case to Proceed (263) 5.00
03/07/25 e Entry DENYING Motion to Disqualify (264) 5.00
Magistrate and Motion to Reconsider
Disqualification
03/07/25 mc Defendant (In His Individual Capacity) (265) .00
Donald Lee Lower's Memorandum Contra to
Plaintiff's Motion for Evidentiary Fact
Stipulations
03/07/25 cos Certificate of Service (265) .00
03/07/25 mc Executor Donald Lee Lowers's (266) .00
Memorandum in Opposition to Michael
Lower's Motion for Evidentiary Fact
Stipulations
03/07/25 cos Certificate of Service (266) .00
03/11/25 e Judgment Entry on Motion for Leave to (267) 5.00
Join Party and File an Amended Complaint
is DENIED.
03/14/25 rep Plaintiff's Reply to Defendant (In His (268) 8.00
Individual Capacity) Donald Lee Lower's
Memorandum Contra to Plaintiff's Motion
for Evidentiary Fact Stipulations
03/14/25 cos Certificate of Service (268) .00
03/14/25 eb Exhibit 1 (268) .00
03/14/25 rep Plaintiff's Response to Executor (269) 8.00
Donlad Lee Lower's Memorandum
in Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion
for Evidentiary Fact Stipulations
03/14/25 cos Certificate of Service (269) .00
03/14/25 eb Exhibit (269) .00
03/14/25 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 641126 31.00
04/10/25 mo Magistrate's Order on Motion to Compel (270) 6.00
and Motion for Better Discovery
04/11/25 jcos Certificate of Service/Judicial Staff (271) .00
04/22/25 17d Magistrate's Decision Denying Motion for (272) 8.00
Continuance, Denying Motion for
Factual Stipulations and Granting
Motions for Summary Judgment
04/22/25 jcos Certificate of Service/Judicial Staff (273) .00
04/22/25 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 643268 22.00
04/22/25 md MOTION DOCKET: Motion to Set Aside (274) 8.00
Magistrate's Order of April 10, 2025 Re:
Responses and/or Better Responses to
Plaintiff's Discovery
04/22/25 cos Certificate of Service (274) .00
04/22/25 eb Exhibit 1 (274) .00
05/01/25 m18ob Plaintiff's Civ.R.53 Objections to the (275) 12.00
Magistrate's Decision Findings of Fact
and Conclusions of Law Re: Magistrate
Order of April 22, 2025, Recommending
05/01/25 ex Summary Judgment in Favor of (275) .00
Defendant Donald Lower
05/01/25 cos Certificate of Service (275) .00
05/01/25 att Filings from March 06, 2025 (275) .00
05/01/25 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 643773 12.00
06/27/25 e Entry Denying Motion to Set Aside (276) 5.00
Magistrate's Order
06/27/25 17n Entry Overruling Objections and Adopting (277) 5.00
Magistrate's Decision
06/30/25 jcos Certificate of Service/Judicial Staff (278) .00
07/11/25 misc Affidavit of Disqualification, ORC 2101, (279) 12.00
Directed to Franklin County Probate
Judge Jeffrey D Mackey
07/11/25 cos Certificate of Service (279) .00
07/11/25 misc Filing by the Supreme Court of Ohio (280) .00
07/16/25 misc Entry from Supreme court re affidavit (281) .00
to disqualify Judge Mackey
07/16/25 misc Judgment entry denying affidavit of (282) 4.00
disqualification
07/23/25 misc Defendant's Discovery Response and (283) 4.00
Plaintiff's Request for Judical Notice
07/23/25 cos Certificate of Service (283) .00
07/23/25 eb Exhibits 1 & 2 (283) .00
07/23/25 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 648280 30.00
07/24/25 m39 Plaintiff's Notice of Appeal (284) .00
(Civil/Mental)
07/24/25 eb Exhibit 1 (284) .00
07/24/25 cos Certificate of Service (284) .00
07/24/25 ds Docketing Statement (285) .00
07/24/25 ad Additional Deposit Rec # 648375 75.00
07/24/25 m39 Plaintiff's Notice of Appeal Re: (286) .00
Judgment Entry Denying Motion to Set
Aside Magistrate's Order
07/24/25 eb Exhibit 1 (286) .00
07/24/25 cos Certificate of Service (286) .00
07/24/25 ds Docketing Statement (287) .00
07/24/25 md MOTION DOCKET: Motion for Fee (288) .00
Wavier Ohio 10th District Court of
Appeals
07/24/25 cos Certificate of Service (288) .00
05/15/26 2.1 Notice of Counsel (289) .00
05/15/26 cos Certificate of Service (289) .00
06/10/26 misc Court of Appeals of Ohio-Tenth (290) .00
Appellate District-Journal Entry
06/10/26 misc Court of Appeals of Ohio-Tenth (291) 10.00
Appellate District-Decision
07/22/26 m39 Notice of Appeal-Court of Appeals of (292) .00
Ohio-Tenth Appellate District
DEPOSIT REMAINING 65.00
View Plaintiffs
View Defendants
New Search
Probate Homepage